← Blog

At the Bottom, Physics. At the Top, Philosophy.

By Carles Carrera · November 2026

I was listening to Modern Wisdom when I heard a story that immediately appealed to me.

Apparently, people have long claimed that talking or singing to plants helps them grow.

The romantic explanation is that plants somehow respond to attention, affection or music.

Then came a much simpler explanation: when you talk to a plant, you breathe CO₂ around it. Plants use CO₂ for photosynthesis.

My first reaction was:

Of course. Physics again.

It reinforced something I increasingly believe: underneath many things we explain through stories, psychology or culture, there is often a much simpler physical mechanism.

Except there was a problem.

When I looked into it, the explanation wasn't nearly as clean as it sounded.

CO₂ certainly helps plants grow under the right conditions. But there isn't good evidence that the amount you exhale while talking to your houseplants is enough to explain the effect.

There are much more mundane possibilities.

Someone who talks to their plants probably also looks at them more. Waters them more carefully. Notices pests earlier. Moves them toward better light.

And I realised something slightly embarrassing.

I had immediately accepted the CO₂ explanation because it fitted something I already wanted to believe.

Which is exactly the opposite of first-principles thinking.

Still, the episode left me thinking about something bigger.

Is everything ultimately physics?

In one sense, almost certainly.

Chemistry doesn't escape physics.

Biology doesn't escape chemistry.

Our brains don't escape biology.

And economics, business, psychology and culture ultimately involve physical human beings making decisions in a world constrained by energy, resources and time.

But saying something can ultimately be reduced to physics doesn't mean physics is always the best way to understand it.

A computer program is ultimately electrons moving through transistors.

That doesn't mean semiconductor physics is the best way to debug software.

The same applies to economics, psychology or business. They are higher-level abstractions that help us understand complexity at the scale where it becomes useful.

And then there is mathematics.

Physics tells us what reality allows.

Mathematics reveals the patterns inside it: probability, compounding, growth, risk, waves, trajectories, networks.

It keeps appearing everywhere.

But even physics and mathematics eventually run into a different kind of question.

What should we do with what we know?

Physics can't tell me whether another hour working is more valuable than another hour riding a motorcycle.

Mathematics can calculate expected value, but it cannot tell me what I should value.

That's where philosophy enters.

So perhaps my original thought was too reductive.

The other disciplines matter enormously.

But underneath them, I keep coming back to three things:

Physics constrains reality.

Mathematics reveals its patterns.

Philosophy asks what any of it means.

Everything else may simply be the fascinating mess that happens in between.